Ryan Cole - Jr., Goalkeeper, Orchard Park, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Defensive Performer of the Week (4/16/2012)

Matt Davidson - Sr., Defense, Hilton, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star

Corey Herrington - Fr., Attack, Camillus, NY
- Liberty League Second-Team All-Star
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (3/5/2012)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (4/9/2012)
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (4/30/2012)

Shane Farrell- Sr., Defense, Webster, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Brian Freeland - So., Defense, East Berlin, CT
- Liberty League All-Academic

Eric Gollands - Sr., Midfield, Chelmsford, MA
- USILA All-America - Honorable Mention
- Liberty League First-Team All-Star
- North-South Game Participant
- USILA Scholar All-America
- Liberty League All-Academic

Peter Goss - So., Attack, Jamesville, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Bryan Huff - Sr., Attack, Hillsborough, NJ
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star
- Liberty League All-Academic

Tim Krauss - So., Midfield, Niskayuna, NY
- Liberty League All-Academic

Matt McCabe - Jr., Midfield, Syracuse, NY
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star

Brendon Shearin - Jr., Midfield, Goffstown, NH
- Liberty League Honorable Mention All-Star