Andrew Bachman - Sr., A, Queensbury, NY/Queensbury
- Liberty League All-Academic

Matt Cyr - Fr., M, Cheshire, CT/Bridgton Academy
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (4/20/09)

Greg Gibbons - Sr., A, Baldwinsville, NY/CW Baker
- 2009 USILA All-America - Honorable Mention
- 2009 North/South Game Participant
- 2009 Liberty League First Team All-Star
- 2009 All-NYS First Team
- 2009 ECAC Upstate All-Star
- Liberty League Co-Offensive Performer of the Week (3/30)
- Liberty League Co-Offensive Performer of the Week (4/6)
- ECAC Upstate Division III Co-Offensive Player of the Week (3/30)
- ECAC Upstate Division III Co-Offensive Player of the Week (4/6)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Brian Hoey - Sr., M, Auburn, NY/Auburn
- 2009 Liberty League First Team All-Star

Bryan Huff - Fr., A, Hillsborough, NJ/Hillsborough
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (3/23)

Andrew Kott - Sr., D, Auburn, NY/Auburn
- 2009 Liberty League First Team All-Star
- 2009 All-NYS Second Team
- 2009 ECAC Upstate All-Star
- Liberty League Co-Defensive Performer of the Week (3/9)
- Liberty League Co-Defensive Performer of the Week (3/16)

Tyler Long - So., M, Liverpool, NY/Liverpool
- 2009 Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention

Tom Ross - Sr., A, Adams, NY/South Jefferson
- 2009 Liberty League Second Team All-Star

Cory Schneider - Sr., M, Yorktown, NY/Yorktown
- Liberty League All-Academic

John Szvoren - Sr., G, Hamburg, NY/Canisius
- Liberty League Defensive Performerof the Week (4/13)

John Weinhold - Sr., D, Queensbury, NY/Glens Falls
- 2009 Liberty League All-Star Honorable Mention