Dave Donegan - Sr., Camillus, NY/West Genesee
- Liberty League All-Academic

Craig Fisher - So., Rochester, NY/Gates Chili
- Liberty League All-Academic\

Gerard Flynn - Jr., Liverpool, NY/Liverpool
- Liberty League All-Academic

Cheryl Josephs - Jr., Potsdam, NY/Potsdam
- Liberty League All-Academic

Christine Lewicki - Sr., Olean, NY/Olean
- Liberty League All-Academic

Emily MacWilliams - Jr., Watkins Glen, NY/Watkins Glen
- Liberty League All-Academic

Sarah Morris - Sr., Amherst, NY/Amherst
- Liberty League Swimmer of the Week (11/21/05)
- Liberty League All-Academic

Krissy Nelson - Jr., Purling, NY/Cairo-Durham
- Liberty League All-Academic

Anne Parken - Jr., Painted Post, NY/Corning Painted Post
- Liberty League All-Academic

Jon Peck - Sr., East Hartford, CT/East Hartford
- Liberty League All-Academic

Nate Willsey - So., Baldwinsville, NY/C.W. Baker
- Liberty League All-Academic

Matt Ulsh - Fr., Rochester, MN/Mayo
- Liberty League Rookie of the Week (11/21/05)
- Liberty League Co-Rookie of the Week (2/27/06)